EUROVISION SONG CONTEST
2019
Semi-Final 2

Winner Semi 2:

The NETHERLANDS

Pavillion 2, Tel Aviv Convention Centre, Tel Aviv, 16 th May 2019
18 countries

Final Semi-Final 1


Netherlands

North Macedonia

Sweden

Switzerland

Azerbaijan

Russia

Norway

Malta

Albania

Denmark

Lithuania

Moldova

Romania

Croatia

Latvia

Armenia

Austria

Ireland
   

          (Jury) (Tele)
1
Netherlands
Duncan Laurence
Arcade
280
140
140
2
North Macedonia
Tamara Todevska
Proud
239
155
84
3
Sweden
John Lundvik
Too Late For Love
238
150
88
4
Switzerland
Luca Hänni
She Got Me
232
95
137
5
Azerbaijan
Chingiz
Truth
224
103
121
6
Russia
Sergey Lazarev
Scream
217
93
124
7
Norway
KEIINO
Spirit In The Sky
210
40
170
8
Malta
Michela Pace
Chameleon
157
107
50
9
Albania
Jonida Maliqi
Ktheju Tokës
96
38
58
10
Denmark
Leonora
Love Is Forever
94
53
41
11
Lithuania
Jurijus Veklenko
Run With The Lions
93
16
77
12
Moldova
Anna Odobescu
Stay
85
58
27
13
Romania
Ester Peony
On A Sunday
71
47
24
14
Croatia
Roko Blaževic
The Dream
64
26
38
15
Latvia
Carousel
That Night
50
37
13
16
Armenia
Srbuk
Walking Out
49
26
23
17
Austria
PAENDA
Limits
21
21
0
18 Ireland
Sarah McTernan
22
16
13
3
  United Kingdom [voting rights only]  
  Germany [voting rights only]  
  Italy [voting rights only]  

JURY
ALB
ARM
AUT
AZE
CRO
DEN
GER
IRE
ITA
LAT
LIT
MAL
MOL
NET
NMA
NOR
ROM
RUS
SWE
SWI
UK
NMC
12
8
8
10
12
10
12
6
7
5
2
2
10
4
7
10
10
8
12
155
SWE
7
12
12
4
12
7
12
12
10
10
12
4
12
4
10
10
150
NET
4
4
10
4
8
7
10
8
4
8
12
12
6
10
8
1
10
12
2
140
MAL
6
10
2
6
6
6
4
10
4
3
7
10
7
4
5
8
4
4
1
107
AZE
10
6
7
1
3
5
6
10
8
7
6
1
8
6
7
4
1
7
103
SWI
5
6
7
2
10
4
8
10
5
8
5
8
3
2
12
95
RUS
8
7
12
3
3
3
4
8
8
7
10
3
6
7
1
3
93
MOL
3
5
3
2
5
6
2
12
5
6
5
4
58
DEN
4
5
3
12
7
1
3
5
3
2
2
6
53
ROM
2
8
4
2
1
12
1
12
5
47
NOR
1
3
8
2
7
1
4
3
5
6
40
ALB
7
5
3
2
12
2
7
38
LAT
3
5
6
5
7
3
1
7
37
CRO
2
5
5
1
5
8
26
ARM
1
1
2
2
6
4
2
2
6
26
AUT
1
2
1
1
1
6
1
8
21
LIT
1
6
3
3
3
16
IRE
8
5
13

TELE
ALB
ARM
AUT
AZE
CRO
DEN
GER
IRE
ITA
LAT
LIT
MAL
MOL
NET
NMA
NOR
ROM
RUS
SWE
SWI
UK
NOR
12
5
10
5
10
12
10
10
8
8
8
8
4
12
3
5
8
12
10
10
170
NET
10
10
6
8
7
8
8
8
3
7
6
10
7
8
5
6
7
5
6
5
140
SWI
6
8
12
10
8
6
12
6
6
3
4
12
6
8
2
7
7
4
4
6
137
RUS
2
12
4
12
3
3
7
7
7
12
10
5
10
3
7
4
8
3
3
2
124
AZA
7
7
5
7
4
3
4
6
7
4
8
7
5
6
10
12
8
4
7
121
SWE
4
4
1
3
4
10
5
5
4
5
7
10
1
10
1
2
8
4
88
NMC
8
6
5
7
12
1
6
1
2
6
6
1
4
6
6
7
84
LIT
5
2
4
1
12
10
3
5
2
12
1
7
1
12
77
ALB
3
4
6
2
12
12
2
3
2
12
58
MAL
7
6
2
5
4
2
2
1
3
1
4
3
2
8
50
DEN
1
1
2
1
2
5
3
2
4
8
10
2
41
CRO
3
2
8
1
3
1
1
10
3
1
5
38
MOL
3
2
5
12
5
27
ROM
1
10
12
1
24
ARM
2
5
6
10
23
LAT
12
1
13
IRE
3
3
AUT
0

 

From wiwibloggs.com:

The Eurovision grand final would normally see the speculation over who would place where at the contest finally come to rest, with the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) revealing the complete and finite results after the confetti has fallen. However, in 2019, the drama around the voting is still very much alive over a week after the contest came to an end. And it doesn’t seem to be dying down any time soon.

Yet another possible discrepancy in the voting has recently emerged – this time from the Italian televote in semi-final two. As a result, the Lithuanian broadcaster LRT is now seeking clarification on the matter.

So what exactly is the discrepancy that LRT is inquiring to the EBU about?

Yesterday, Italian broadcaster RAI published the full Italian televote results from both semi-final two and the grand final. Although the latter of these aligns with the results published by the EBU, the former does not.
Italian semi-final two televote results as published by Left: EBU, and Right: RAI

EBU Published Results:
Albania – 12 points
Romania – 10 points
Norway – 8 points
Russia – 7 points
Switzerland – 6 points
Moldova – 5 points
Azerbaijan – 4 points
The Netherlands – 3 points
Malta – 2 points
North Macedonia – 1 point

RAI Published Results:
Albania – 16.08% (12 pts)
Romania – 10.39% (10 pts)
Russia – 9.92% (8 pts)
Moldova – 8.66% (7 pts)
Norway – 8.58% (6 pts)
Switzerland – 5.93% (5 pts)
North Macedonia – 5.47% (4 pts)
Azerbaijan – 5.40% (3 pts)
Malta – 4.42% (2 pts)
Lithuania – 4.13% (1 pt)

If the results published by RAI are indeed the correct televote results (Eurovision fan-site ESCXtra contacted a member of the Italian delegation who stated that they were), this would see Russia, Moldova, North Macedonia and Lithuania each gain points, while Norway, Switzerland, Azerbaijan and The Netherlands would all lose points.

The most significant of these changes is Lithuania’s jump up to tenth place and one point gain. Although this seems a relatively small change, the current overall standings of semi-final two show that the Baltic country finished in eleventh place, just one point behind tenth-place qualifier Denmark. The change in results would see both Lithuania and Denmark tie for tenth position on 94 points.

The current rules for tiebreakers associated with ties for last position in the semi-final state: “Should there be a tie for the last position in a Semi-Final (because two songs have received the same number of points)…the winner shall be the song which has obtained the highest rank from all the National Audiences [televote]”.

Therefore, since Lithuania received 77 points from the televote in semi-final two, where as Denmark received 41 points, Lithuania would win any possible tiebreak situation.
This leaves the question, should Lithuania have qualified to the grand final of Eurovision 2019 instead of Denmark?

It is possible that the EBU and their voting monitor Ernst & Young discovered some errors in RAI’s calculations that were later corrected without the broadcaster’s knowledge. However, until the EBU officially comments on the matter we can only speculate on what could have been.
LRT seeks clarification from EBU

After hearing about the discrepancy in results, Lithuania’s Head of Delegation at Eurovision, Audrius Giržadas, confirmed that the broadcaster would be formally applying to the EBU to ask for clarifications about the Italian televote result:

"The situation is really interesting. We, as a broadcaster, have suffered moral and rating misconduct, and we may have enough to acknowledge the error.
Audrius also comments that Lithuania’s Eurovision 2019 representative, Jurij Veklenko, could be due compensation for the error:
The songwriter and performer could claim substantial financial compensation – when the song is performed to such a large audience, the author’s reward for playing the song twice is significantly higher than when it it is performed only once."

However, speaking to LRT.lt himself, Jurij remains unfazed by the situation and says his job is to focus on the music rather than the money:

"I did everything I could, but it happened as it happened. Those who were in the finals were worthy of it, and I don’t see the point of unnecessarily hitting or depriving them of their place in the table. I think [my managers] will decide whether to take action and my job is to create music."


What if other semi-final two ‘mistakes’ were corrected?

This most recent voting discrepancy follows on from the correction to the grand final results last week, after “human error” led to the incorrect aggregated result being used for the Belorussian jury.

However, this is not the first potential mistake in the results of the second semi-final. It was earlier reported that Swedish juror, and former Alcazar singer, Lina Hedlund had ranked the songs in the reverse order – putting her favourite song, Duncan Laurence’s “Arcade” for the Netherlands, last and her least favourite tune, PAENDA’s “Limits”, first.

This affected the points given by the Swedish jury. If Lina’s song order had been correct and new averages for the Swedish jury calculated, the revised guesstimate of the Swedish results (without applying the EBU’s weighting system) would see Denmark gain two points and Lithuania lose one.
If this possible error was also corrected, in addition to the discrepancy in the Italian televote results, then Denmark would remain in tenth position, with 96 points. Lithuania would instead be three points behind on 93 points and still in the non-qualification eleventh place.

It is important to note that neither Lina, Swedish broadcaster SVT or the EBU have commented on this matter.
Therefore, like the discrepancy in the Italian televote, this ‘mistake’ is still not official. Although highly unlikely, maybe the “Victorious” hit-maker really did have a complete change of heart in the two days between the second semi-final and the grand final, which resulted in her placing The Netherlands last in the former and first in the latter.

Further reports indicate that Russian juror Igor Gulyaev may have also ranked his preferred songs in the wrong order during semi-final two. The full results show he placed Denmark first in the semi-final, but last in the grand final (the opposite for Azerbaijan, which he ranked last and first respectively).

If Igor’s semi-final ranking was a mistake, the revised guesstimate of the Russian jury votes would see Denmark lose the three points it was initially awarded. Adding this change to the two others mentioned above would see Denmark fall to 93 points, and once again be tied with Lithuania for tenth place.

As always, until the EBU officially comments on the matter and confirms any possible errors in the voting, this is all speculation.

go to 2018

Back to Home Page

go to 1956